The Marshall Trilogy: How Three Supreme Court Cases Built Tribal Sovereignty
By Daniel R. Whitfield
Length4h 42m
About this audiobook
Pope Nicholas V's bull of January 1455 gave the king of Portugal license to "invade, search out, capture, vanquish, and subdue" every non-Christian people his ships could reach, and to take their lands and goods for the crown. Three hundred and sixty-eight years later, ruling on land that the Illinois and Piankeshaw nations had sold to a company of speculators in the 1770s, Chief Justice John Marshall wrote the same idea into American law. He called it discovery.
Here Marshall's three great Indian cases are read as a single argument. Johnson v. McIntosh (1823) left Native nations the right to occupy their land but not to sell it to anyone except the government. Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831) named them "domestic dependent nations." Worcester v. Georgia (1832) held that Georgia's laws had no force inside the Cherokee Nation, and Georgia ignored it while President Jackson made no move to enforce it. The Indian Removal Act had been law since 1830.
Around the cases stand the people who lived them: the Cherokee who wrote a constitution and printed a newspaper in their own syllabary, the missionary who went to a Georgia prison rather than swear an oath to the state, the leaders who split over the Treaty of New Echota, and the thousands forced west on the Trail of Tears. From there the doctrine travels west with the removed nations and on through the twentieth century to McGirt v. Oklahoma in 2020.
The contradiction at the heart of Marshall's opinions, a nation at once sovereign and dependent, is the foundation federal Indian law still stands on.
Audiobook details
GenreHistory
Length4 hrs 42 mins
Narrated byListen with 1,000+ voices
FormateBook with Audio
Publish dateSep 19, 2026
LanguageEnglish
Table of contents
1Chapter 1: Before the Doctrine
2Chapter 2: A Court of Nine Men in a New Capital
3Chapter 3: Johnson v. McIntosh, 1823: The Land and the Lie
4Chapter 4: Georgia's Law and the Cherokee Constitution
5Chapter 5: Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 1831: What Kind of Nation?
Show all chaptersShow less
6Chapter 6: The Missionary and the Jailhouse Door
7Chapter 7: Worcester v. Georgia, 1832: The Law of Nations
8Chapter 8: The Removal Winter, 1832-1834
9Chapter 9: The Treaty of New Echota and the Trail of Tears
10Chapter 10: After Marshall: The Doctrine in the West
11Chapter 11: Twentieth-Century Reckoning
12Chapter 12: The Doctrine Today
13About the Author
More from Daniel R. Whitfield
Jim Thorpe: The Greatest Athlete and the Fight for His MedalsDaniel R. Whitfield4h 19m$6
Ninety Million Acres: The Dawes Act and the Theft of Indian LandDaniel R. Whitfield4h 47m$6
The Osage Empire Before OilDaniel R. Whitfield4h 38m$6
The World They Made: Native America in 1491Daniel R. Whitfield4h 24m$6
The Prophet and the Confederacy: Tenskwatawa, Tippecanoe, and the War for Native PowerDaniel R. Whitfield4h 17m$6
Ely Parker: The Seneca Engineer Who Wrote the Surrender at AppomattoxDaniel R. Whitfield3h 27m4.6 (11)$6
The Chickasaw Wars: The Nation That Never SurrenderedDaniel R. Whitfield3h 55m$6
The Kiowa and the Southern Plains: Horse Trade, Sun Dance, and the Long Road to ReservationDaniel R. Whitfield4h 50m$6
A Brief History of IntelligenceMax S. Bennett12h 18m4.6 (6.6K)$29 · $0.00
Ghosts of HiroshimaCharles Pellegrino8h 59m4.5 (877)$23
Lily's PromiseLily Ebert, Dov Forman8h 54m4.6 (16.1K)$29 · $0.00
On Democracies and Death CultsDouglas Murray10h 38m4.6 (6.5K)$29 · $0.00
Across the RiverKent Babb11h 40m4.6 (927)$29 · $0.00
Balcony Over Jerusalem: A Middle East Memoir - Israel, Palestine and BeyondJohn Lyons12h 37m4.6 (1.4K)$33 · $0.00
BeyondStephen Walker15h 39m4.6 (3.2K)$33 · $0.00
Kings and PawnsHoward Bryant10h 9m4.6 (678)$29 · $0.00
No EscapeNury Turkel9h 30m4.6 (809)$28 · $0.00
Jubal Stone: U.S. Marshal: Blood Trail To Hell: A Western Adventure NovelCasey Nash3h 42m4.6 (3.2K)$18 · $0.00
Fall and RiseMitchell Zuckoff17h 23m4.6 (9.8K)$40 · $0.00
The SurvivorJosef Lewkowicz, Michael Calvin9h 22m4.6 (2.5K)$29 · $0.00
Always FaithfulThomas Schueman, Zainullah Zaki12h 12m4.6 (977)$29 · $0.00
The State of Society in France Before the Revolution of 1789 (Annotated)Alexis de Tocqueville17h 25m4.6 (1.2K)$2 · $0.00
All the Gallant MenDonald Stratton, Ken Gire5h 55m4.6 (11.8K)$24 · $0.00
Medgar and MyrlieJoy-Ann Reid10h 52m4.5 (27.8K)$29 · $0.00
The History of the Peloponnesian War (Annotated)Thucydides24h 3m4.6 (1.1K)$2 · $0.00
Where the Birds Never SingJack Sacco10h 31m4.6 (3.8K)$29 · $0.00
Serviceman J: The Untold Story of an NZSAS SoldierJamie Pennell5h 51m4.6 (452)$24 · $0.00
Valley of the BirdtailAndrew Stobo Sniderman, Douglas Sanderson10h 1m4.6 (2.4K)$29 · $0.00
You may also like
A Kidnapped WestMilan Kundera1h 25m4.3 (2.1K)$16 · $0.00
Reconstruction Updated EditionEric Foner31h 33m4.4 (11.8K)$53 · $0.00
God and Man at YaleWilliam F. Buckley Jr.6h 41m3.9 (2.8K)$17 · $0.00
The Holy Bible - 3 JohnKing James2m4.5 (312)$3 · $0.00
On The Duty of Civil DisobedienceDavid Thoreau1h 6m4.0 (115K)$1 · $0.00
Christianity and WokenessOwen Strachan7h 59m4.3 (1.2K)$20
We Crossed a Bridge and It TrembledWendy Pearlman6h4.6 (5.2K)$24 · $0.00
The American Indian Under ReconstructionAnnie Heloise Abel7h 19m4.0 (11)$1 · $0.00
The JewsHilaire Belloc8h 27m4.1 (156)$2.30
The Slaveholding Indians (Vol.1-3)Annie Heloise Abel36h 23m4.3 (31)$1 · $0.00
Handbook of Home Rule: Being Articles on the Irish QuestionJohn Morley, Viscount James Bryce Bryce, Edwin Lawrence Godkin, W. E. Gladstone, R. Barry O'Brien, Malcolm MacColl, Baron Henry Thring Thring9h 48m$2 · $0.00
Cessions of Land by Indian Tribes to the United States: Illustrated by Those in the State of IndianaCharles C. Royce0m$1 · $0.00
The Early History of the Scottish Union QuestionGeorge W. T. Omond2h 55m$2 · $0.00
The History of Moors in Spain (Summarized Edition)Stanley Lane-Poole3h 5m$2
Deportation Its Meaning and Menace: Last Message to the People of AmericaEmma Goldman, Alexander Berkman2h 10m4.0 (28)$1 · $0.00
Ireland and the Home Rule MovementMichael Sir McDonnell5h 42m$2 · $0.00
Who fears to speak of '98Anonymous54m$1 · $0.00
Peter of New AmsterdamJames Otis3h 1m$10
The Communist Collection: 14 Insightful BooksJoseph J. Mereto, Petr Alekseevich kniaz Kropotkin, Lewis Henry Berens, Leon Trotsky, Mary Knight, Sergiei Nilus, Tommaso Campanella, Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Hermynia Zur MÃ1⁄4hlen, Boris Reinstein, Mack Reynolds, John Spargo, Paul Dukes, Bertrand Russell133h 15m$1.99 · $0.00
JosephusNorman Bentwich7h 58m3.7 (54)$2 · $0.00