Length11h 10m
About this audiobook
In the shadowy underbelly of small-town America, where faith and family hide unimaginable horrors, Betty Neumar reigned as the ultimate predator. Born into Depression-era poverty in Ohio, Betty transformed from a seemingly devout preacher's wife into a ruthless serial murderer, leaving a trail of five dead husbands across four states over six decades. Dubbed the "All American Black Widow," she exploited religious communities as hunting grounds, charming lonely widowers with scripture and smiles before systematically poisoning, shooting, or staging their deaths for insurance payouts and inheritances.
From her first victim, Harold Guthrie, shot in the head in 1952 while she claimed a robbery, to her last, Al Gentry, murdered in 2007 amid echoes of her original alibi, Betty's crimes evaded detection through cunning relocations and jurisdictional blind spots. She wasn't driven by rage or ritual—she killed for profit, manipulating social security, life insurance, and assets with chilling precision. Drawing on exhaustive research, court records, forensic reports, and interviews with victims' families, author Miguel A. Baughman unravels this true crime saga of deception and death.
As detectives finally connected the dots in a groundbreaking multi-state investigation, Betty's facade crumbled, exposing a female serial killer who outsmarted the system longer than most live. This gripping narrative explores the psychology of a master manipulator, the evolution of cold case forensics, and the vulnerabilities in America's heartland churches that allowed her to thrive.
This chilling true crime biography digs into intimate partner violence, financial exploitation, and the quest for justice denied by Betty's untimely death before trial. A haunting reminder that evil often wears the mask of piety, "The All American Black Widow" will keep you questioning every charming stranger.
Audiobook details
GenrePolitics and Government, Education and Learning
Length11 hrs 10 mins
Narrated byListen with 1,000+ voices
FormateBook with Audio
Publish dateSep 12, 2025
LanguageEnglish
Table of contents
1Prologue
2Chapter 1: The Last Husband
3Chapter 2: Foundations of Faith And Deception
4Chapter 3: First Blood: James Flynn
5Chapter 4: The Widow's Progress
Show all chaptersShow less
6Chapter 5: Richard Sills: The Businessman
7Chapter 6: John Neumar: The Preacher
8Chapter 7: Harold Guthrie: Perfecting the Method
9Chapter 8: Al Gentry: The Final Victim
10Chapter 9: Cold Case Renaissance
11Chapter 10: The Web Unravels
12Chapter 11: The Net Closes
13Chapter 12: Building the Case
14Chapter 13: Death Before Justice
15Chapter 14: Legacy of The Black Widow
16Epilogue
17Appendix A: Timeline of Events
18Appendix B: Victim Profiles
19Appendix C: Legal Framework Analysis
More from Miguel A. Baughman
Poursuivre MansonMiguel A. Baughman12h 23m$10
Prosecuting MansonMiguel A. Baughman9h 45m$10
Anklage Gegen MansonMiguel A. Baughman12h 6m$10
Il Processo A MansonMiguel A. Baughman12h 23m$10
Procesar A MansonMiguel A. Baughman12h 12m$10
Erinnerung An WacoMiguel A. Baughman8h 43m$9
Ricordando WacoMiguel A. Baughman8h 39m$9
Remembering WacoMiguel A. Baughman7h 30m$9
Sulle Tracce Del Predatore Del 21° SecoloMiguel A. Baughman8h 8m$8
Un Monstre AméricainMiguel A. Baughman7h 35m$8
Inside American ViolenceMiguel A. Baughman7h 11m$8
Killers Under the Osage MoonMiguel A. Baughman8h 22m$8
An American MonsterMiguel A. Baughman6h 44m$8
Framed by LiesMiguel A. Baughman8h 47m$8
How to Test Negative for StupidJohn Kennedy8h 13m4.7 (9.7K)$28 · $0.00
Black AF HistoryMichael Harriot15h 43m4.7 (14.6K)$33 · $0.00
The Gulag Archipelago Volume 3Aleksandr I. Solzhenitsyn21h 56m4.7 (8.9K)$46 · $0.00
MotherlandJulia Ioffe17h 52m4.7 (2.5K)$40 · $0.00
HostageEli Sharabi5h 25m4.6 (10.8K)$24 · $0.00
KrantikariSanjeev Sanyal11h 44m4.6 (1.3K)$16 · $0.00
Unbroken Bonds of BattleJohnny Joey Jones8h 31m4.6 (2.6K)$8 · $0.00
On Democracies and Death CultsDouglas Murray10h 38m4.6 (6.5K)$29 · $0.00
Balcony Over Jerusalem: A Middle East Memoir - Israel, Palestine and BeyondJohn Lyons12h 37m4.6 (1.4K)$33 · $0.00
RiggedMollie Hemingway12h 48m4.6 (4.2K)$23 · $0.00
SledgehammerDavid Friedman8h 21m4.7 (589)$26 · $0.00
Citizenship in a Republic (Annotated)Theodore Roosevelt2h 44m4.6 (1.4K)$2 · $0.00
No EscapeNury Turkel9h 30m4.6 (809)$28 · $0.00
Always FaithfulThomas Schueman, Zainullah Zaki12h 12m4.6 (977)$29 · $0.00
UnthinkableJamie Raskin15h 8m4.5 (9.3K)$8 · $0.00
My Fourth Time, We DrownedSally Hayden13h 59m4.6 (2.9K)$23 · $0.00
A Revolution of Common SenseScott Jennings9h 29m4.6 (528)$29 · $0.00
Statement From the Dock at the Rivonia TrialNelson Mandela2h 18m4.6 (1.3K)$1 · $0.00
Lessons from the EdgeMarie Yovanovitch17h 11m4.5 (5.9K)$40 · $0.00
To Rescue the American SpiritBret Baier10h 12m4.5 (2.7K)$8 · $0.00
A Brief History of IntelligenceMax S. Bennett12h 18m4.6 (6.6K)$29 · $0.00
HomeschooledStefan Merrill Block7h 10m3.6 (18.5K)$28 · $0.00
How We ThinkJohn Dewey7h 6m4.0 (1.1K)Free
Life on the BridgeKaelynn Partlow5h 40m4.6 (1.1K)$24 · $0.00
EXPERIENCE AND EDUCATION – Premium Edition (Including Democracy & Education) (Annotated)John Dewey19h 17m4.6 (1K)$2 · $0.00
WitnessAriel Burger8h 1m4.6 (1.3K)$20 · $0.00
EducationEllen G. White9h 41m4.6 (1.5K)$2 · $0.00
Parents and Children (Annotated)Charlotte Mason9h 23m4.6 (988)$2 · $0.00
Children Under FireJohn Woodrow Cox10h 17m4.5 (1.6K)$29 · $0.00
The State Must ProvideAdam Harris7h 15m4.5 (775)$24 · $0.00
The Call of the Wild and FreeAinsley Arment9h 7m4.4 (21.2K)$29 · $0.00
The Freelance WayRobert Vlach19h 48m4.5 (528)$40 · $0.00
Race to the BottomLuke Rosiak9h 20m4.5 (600)$29 · $0.00
They Came for the SchoolsMike Hixenbaugh9h 5m4.5 (2.6K)$8 · $0.00
Find Me UnafraidKennedy Odede, Jessica Posner11h 11m4.5 (2.7K)$29 · $0.00
Asking for ItKate Harding8h 55m4.4 (5.3K)$20 · $0.00
Defining Moments in Black HistoryDick Gregory7h 37m4.4 (6K)$26 · $0.00
The Emerald Tablets of Thoth the AtlanteanMaurice Doreal3h 4m4.4 (8.8K)$6 · $0.00
Learning AmericaLuma Mufleh6h 37m4.4 (564)$24 · $0.00
Math-ishJo Boaler7h 21m4.4 (588)$24 · $0.00
You may also like
The Lodger (Annotated)Marie Belloc Lowndes9h 37m4.0 (1.3K)$3 · $0.00
A Question of IdentitySusan Hill10h 28m4.0 (11.9K)$30
The LogderMarie Adelaide Belloc Lowndes9h 8m3.7 (4.4K)$2 · $0.00
It's One Of UsJ.T. Ellison11h 38m3.9 (64.9K)$29 · $0.00
The Burnt HouseFaye Kellerman12h 51m4.0 (8.9K)$33 · $0.00
A Caribbean MysteryAgatha Christie5h 34m4.0 (65.9K)$24 · $0.00
Chloe Cates Is MissingMandy McHugh11h 25m3.8 (4.3K)$20 · $0.00
Curtain: Poirot's Last CaseAgatha Christie5h 42m4.2 (79.3K)$24 · $0.00
A Caribbean MysteryAgatha Christie6h 37m4.0 (81.2K)$24 · $0.00
The Lake HouseKate Watterson9h 46m3.8 (1.2K)$20
Her Every FearPeter Swanson10h 51m3.9 (44.3K)$29 · $0.00
Sleep Well, MommyMi-ae Seo8h 52m3.6 (5.2K)$29 · $0.00
The Zebra-Striped HearseRoss Macdonald8h 25m4.1 (4.6K)$17
A Killer MotiveHannah Mary McKinnon10h 20m3.8 (2.3K)$29 · $0.00
A Deadly GameJoanne Griffiths9h 19m4.1 (515)$22 · $0.00
Cards on the TableAgatha Christie6h4.1 (104K)$24 · $0.00
Hickory Dickory DockAgatha Christie6h 3m3.9 (60.2K)$20
The ABC MurdersAgatha Christie6h 1m4.1 (211.3K)$24 · $0.00
Sherlock HolmesMade for Success14h 22m4.5 (4.3K)$25
Midsummer MysteriesAgatha Christie7h 22m3.8 (3.4K)$24 · $0.00